Chapter
9: Rich man, poor man
The
Bible is full of great morality plays expounding the virtues of the
poor and the malevolence of the rich. Mathew quotes Jesus as saying
that it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than
for a rich man to get to heaven. I don't want to get into all the
crazy arguments about whether Jesus intended to be literal. And it
is silly to talk about the alleged misinterpretations assigned to the
eye of the needle. Suffice to say that Jesus wanted us to understand
that most rich people were assholes. They were assholes in his day
and they are assholes today.
Today's
political arguments revolve around this unarguable premise. To hear
a Republican talk, one would think the rich were endowed with virtues
far beyond the capacity of our lower class brains to decipher. They
truly believe it when they say the rich work hard and the poor are
lazy. I have been around both the rich and the poor all my life. I
can honestly say I know of no rich man who works hard. Rich people
think 8 meetings and two plane connections is a hard day. But if
they had to work one shift at McDonalds, they would understand the
true meaning of work.
Most
of this idiocy revolves around the belief that most rich people are
self made men. To the contrary. Most rich men are generationally
wealthy. The top one percent had it given to them. They were born
into it. They work to keep it. They work to keep from being
swindled. They work to make it possible to pass it down to
generation after generation after generation. Their ability to make
more millions on top of what they already have boils down to the same
kind of luck it takes to win at roulette. They spend their days
betting on stocks and bonds and businesses to which they owe little
or no sweat. To call that work is an insult to the working class.
They
never clean a toilet or dig a latrine. They don't have to paint the
eaves or clean out the basement. They don't rake their own leaves or
dig their own weeds. They are mostly leeches on society, grabbing up
most of the profit for themselves. The only value they give to our
society is in the wealth they allow to be used to finance
businesses...the bricks and mortar kind.
When
we prospered, back in the 50s, the rich were taxed at 90 percent.
Politicians knew that most rich people would never have to pay that
rate. But they also knew that if you allowed them to park their
money in high yield bonds and low risk derivatives, they would be
absolutely happy to sit on their millions. That high tax rate pushed
money into the markets. In order to avoid the tax man, the rich
invested in charities and businesses. And boy oh boy did we prosper!
Most
people have never read a single book on economics. I read three this
year. All of them outline the following simple reason for high taxes
on the rich:
If
I am rich, I have a large amount of disposable income. Most middle
class people have nearly none. Disposable income generates demand.
Demand generates middle class prosperity and healthy tax collections.
When disposable income is concentrated at the top as it is now, the
markets starve. Demand is low because one man holding a hundred
million dollars cannot possibly spend his disposable income. But if
ten thousand people hold that same hundred million dollars, chances
are excellent that they will spend a great percentage of it. They
will be able to fix their cars and put insulation in their attics, or
go to a movie or buy a new TV. They will generate demand. They will
stimulate job acquisition.
Rich
people are no more frugal than you or I. They just have no need to
spend their cash as a percentage of income. So giving them tax
breaks will only exaserbate the problem. Giving them tax breaks will
tie up even more money that is never spent.
So
now that you understand the great Republican lie, let's compare that
with the great Christian makeover.
Why
do you think most Catholic Churches have stopped preaching sermons
about the pitfalls of wealth? Whe don't they follow the example set
by Jesus and pillory the rich? Could it be because their most
important benefactors are rich? Could it be that the collection
plate dictates the political stand of the Church?
So
they give Jesus a makeover and strip him of his anti-wealth,
anti-violence message. They pray to Jesus to make them victorious in
war. They pray to Jesus to help them nail that next commission
check. They hobnob with the wealthy and flatter them. And the
wealthy start believing that they do it all by themselves. They dip
into the corporate coffers and scoop up the lion's share of the
profits.
Michael
Moore makes his point in this way: Imagine a large room with a
hundred people standing around waiting to be fed. Everyone is very
hungry and hasn't eaten in days. A man walks in with a large pie cut
into 100 pieces. One of the hungry men walks up to the pie and takes
99 pieces for himself, leaving 1 piece for the other 99 people.
That is how capitalism works in this country. And without the help
of the Christians, it would never fly. Christians have forsaken the
most important message of their great Savior. They have embraced
greed and forsaken generosity.
“But
that's just business!” they will say. That may well be...but Jesus
was specific about this one and today's Christians are diametrically
opposed to his message. There is a way to make capitalism a more
egalitarian pursuit. But reforming it will be impossible until
conservative Christians turn back to Jesus and accept his philosophy.
I'm
not holding my breath.